Erie vs. Amica Homeowners Insurance in 2025 (Head-to-Head Review)

When evaluating Erie vs. Amica homeowners insurance, it’s clear that both companies provide unique programs designed to meet specific homeowner needs.

Erie offers water backup coverage for damages caused by sewer backups and includes identity restoration assistance, helping homeowners recover quickly from theft. Amica, on the other hand, is prominent for providing identity fraud protection that covers legal expenses and credit control.

Erie vs. Amica Homeowners Insurance Review Rating

It also extends insurance to home-based businesses by safeguarding tools and equipment along with potential liability from business activities. Two companies provide specialized solutions that are designed to assist property owners in safeguarding their most valued assets, as well as addressing specific dangers.

For those seeking the best homeowners insurance, secure affordable coverage using our free quote comparison tool.

Compare The Best Insurance Quotes In The Country

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Erie vs. Amica Insurance Pricing Breakdown

This table highlights the monthly rates for full coverage homeowners insurance from Erie and Amica, segmented by age and gender. It clearly compares how rates vary between the two providers across different demographics.

Erie consistently offers lower rates than Amica, with noticeable savings for both genders and all age groups. A sixteen-year-old girl, for example, pays $218 with Erie instead of $695 with Amica, and a sixty-year-old man pays $55 with Erie instead of $140 with Amica.

Erie vs. Amica Full Coverage Homeowners Insurance Monthly Rates by Age & Gender

Evidence shows that Erie is the more economical choice in every category. However, Amica offers other advantages like identity fraud protection, which some people may find justified the increased premiums. Reviewing these rates helps you understand which provider aligns with your budget and priorities.

Choosing the Best Homeowners Insurance: Erie vs. Amica

When considering homeowners insurance, Amica emerges as the superior choice for several compelling reasons:

• Extensive Experience: With a legacy dating back to 1907, Amica has a wealth of experience in providing reliable coverage, instilling confidence in its ability to understand and meet the diverse needs of homeowners.
• Technological Advancements: Amica’s commitment to innovation is evident in its user-friendly online platforms and mobile apps. This tech-savvy approach allows policyholders to effortlessly manage their policies, file claims, and access support, aligning with the preferences of modern homeowners.
• Financial Stability: Amica consistently earns high ratings from leading agencies, indicating a robust financial standing. This stability ensures that the company can fulfill its financial obligations, providing a secure foundation for policyholders.
• Customer Satisfaction: Numerous awards and recognitions for exceptional customer service underscore Amica’s dedication to customer satisfaction. This commitment is crucial to ensuring a positive and reliable insurance experience.
• Comprehensive Coverage Options: Amica’s homeowners insurance goes beyond the basics, offering innovative solutions, customizable coverage options, and additional services such as identity theft protection and coverage for home businesses.

While Erie Insurance presents a commendable history and competitive pricing, Amica’s combination of experience, technological convenience, financial strength, customer satisfaction, comprehensive coverage, and a nationwide presence solidifies its position as the best overall choice for homeowners insurance.

Erie vs. Amica: A Legacy of Service and Innovation

Amica and Erie homeowners insurance have established strong reputations during the years of operation. Finding the ideal fit for your home is made easier with Amica’s nationwide coverage and user-friendly digital tools, while Erie stands out for its reasonable prices and local, individualized care.

Brief History of Erie Insurance

Founded in 1925, ERIE has a rich history of providing reliable coverage to homeowners. What sets Erie apart is its commitment to customer satisfaction and competitive rates. With its headquarters in Erie, Pennsylvania, Erie Insurance has expanded its reach and operates in 12 states.

Erie Insurance Group strongly emphasizes community involvement and giving back. The company actively supports various charitable organizations and initiatives, aiming to impact the communities it serves positively. Additionally, Erie Insurance Exchange takes pride in its strong relationships with local agents, ensuring personalized and attentive service for its policyholders.

Over the years, Erie Insurance Exchange has received numerous accolades and recognition for its exceptional service and financial stability. The company has consistently earned high ratings from independent rating agencies, demonstrating its commitment to financial strength and stability.

Brief History of Amica Insurance

Amica Mutual Insurance Company, on the other hand, was established in 1907. Known for its excellent customer service and comprehensive coverage options, Amica has gained a loyal customer base over the years. Its home office is in Lincoln, Rhode Island, America, and it operates in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Amica Mutual Insurance is committed to providing innovative solutions to meet the evolving needs of homeowners. The company offers a range of coverage options, including protection for homes, personal property, and liability. Amica also provides additional services, such as identity theft protection and coverage for home businesses.

One of the key strengths of Amica Mutual is its focus on technology and digital solutions. The company has invested in user-friendly online platforms and mobile apps, allowing policyholders to easily manage their policies, file claims, and access support. This commitment to technological advancements has earned Amica Mutual Insurance a reputation for being at the forefront of the industry.

Amica Mutual Insurance Company takes pride in its strong financial stability and commitment to policyholder satisfaction. The company has consistently received high ratings from leading rating agencies, reflecting its ability to meet its financial obligations and provide reliable coverage to homeowners nationwide.

Read more: Does Amica homeowners insurance cover AC units?

Compare The Best Insurance Quotes In The Country

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Coverage Options

When selecting a homeowners insurance policy, it’s important to consider the coverage options available. In this section, we will delve into the coverage options offered by both Erie and Amica to help you understand what each provider offers.

Coverage Options Offered by Erie

Erie Insurance offers a range of coverage options tailored to meet the needs of homeowners. These options provide comprehensive protection for your home and personal belongings. Let’s take a closer look at the coverage options offered by ERIE:

• Dwelling Coverage: This option covers the structure of your home, including the walls, roof, and foundation, against various perils such as fire, windstorms, and vandalism.
• Personal Property Coverage: Erie Insurance Group covers your personal belongings, such as furniture, appliances, and clothing. This coverage extends to losses caused by theft, fire, or other covered events.
• Liability Coverage: If someone is injured on your property and you are held legally responsible, Erie’s liability coverage will help protect you. This coverage includes medical expenses and legal costs associated with the incident.
• Additional Living Expenses Coverage: If your home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss, Erie Insurance Exchange will assist in covering the additional living expenses you may incur while your home is being repaired or rebuilt.

Protect your home and possessions from life’s unexpected curveballs with one of Erie Insurance’s many coverage options.

Coverage Options Offered by Amica

Amica Mutual Insurance Company also offers comprehensive coverage options for homeowners. Their policies are designed to provide peace of mind and protect your most valuable assets. Let’s explore the coverage options offered by Amica:

• Dwelling Coverage: Amica’s dwelling coverage protects the structure of your home, including the walls, roof, and attached structures, against a wide range of perils such as fire, lightning, and hail.
• Personal Property Coverage: Similar to Erie, Amica Mutual offers coverage for your personal belongings, ensuring you can replace your possessions in case of theft, damage, or loss due to covered events.
• Liability Coverage: Amica’s liability coverage provides financial protection if you are held responsible for injuries or property damage to others. This coverage helps cover medical expenses and legal costs associated with a liability claim.
• Loss of Use Coverage: If your home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss, Amica Mutual Insurance will assist in covering the additional expenses you may incur while living elsewhere, such as temporary accommodations and meals.

With both Erie Insurance and Amica Insurance, you may find various coverage options to suit your individual needs as a homeowner. It is important to look over the products of each provider and think about your situation before choosing a value ratio of homeowners insurance.

Pricing Comparison

Erie and Amica homeowners insurance are about competitive pricing and meeting your needs. Erie keeps things affordable without skimping coverage, while Amica offers excellent value with flexible policies and discounts. You may tailor your coverage to your property and individual needs with either of these best insurance companies.

Erie Insurance Pricing

Erie Insurance offers competitive pricing for their homeowners insurance policies. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, Erie strives to provide affordable options for homeowners without compromising on the quality of coverage.

Various factors come into play when determining the cost of your Erie homeowners insurance policy. These factors may include your home’s location, your property’s value, and the coverage limits you choose. Erie understands that every homeowner’s needs are unique, and they work closely with their customers to tailor policies that fit their specific requirements.

Erie uses its industry experience to offer fair, competitive pricing. Their rates reflect your property’s risks, providing coverage that fits your budget, whether for a historic or newly built home.

Amica Insurance Pricing

Amica Insurance is known for its competitive pricing structure. Amica is dedicated to providing consumers exceptional coverage and customer care while providing reasonably priced homeowners insurance.

The price of your Amica homeowners insurance policy is determined by a number of factors. These factors may include the age of your home, the location of your property, and the discounts available to you. Amica customizes coverage to meet the particular requirements of every household.

Amica promises to provide outstanding value and protection at low prices regarding the risks connected with your home. Insurance policies from this company strike a good mix between cost and coverage for single-family homes and condominiums.

Discounts and Savings

Finding ways to save money on premiums is always a top priority for homeowners insurance. Luckily, both Erie and Amica offer a range of discounts and savings opportunities to help homeowners reduce their insurance costs.

In this section, we will explore the various discounts available from each provider, giving you a comprehensive understanding of the potential savings you can enjoy.

Discounts Available with Erie

Erie Insurance understands the importance of providing affordable coverage to homeowners. That’s why they offer several discounts to help homeowners save on their premiums.

One of the most popular discounts offered by Erie is the multi-policy discount. You can enjoy significant savings on both policies by bundling your homeowner’s insurance with another policy, such as auto insurance. This simplifies your insurance experience and helps you keep more money in your pocket.

In addition to the multi-policy discount, Erie also offers safety discounts for homeowners who take proactive measures to protect their properties. Erie helps consumers lower hazards and increase home security by providing home fire safety guides and educational resources.

Furthermore, Erie rewards proactive homeowners who plan by offering advanced quote discounts. If you purchase a policy before the renewal date of your current policy, you can enjoy even more savings. This discount encourages homeowners to secure coverage proactively and helps them save money.

Discounts Available with Amica

Amica Insurance is another provider that understands the importance of offering discounts to its policyholders. They offer a range of discounts to help homeowners save money on their insurance premiums.

One of Amica’s key discounts is the multi-line discount. You can enjoy significant savings on both policies by bundling your homeowner’s insurance with another policy, such as auto or life insurance. This simplifies your insurance management and provides you with substantial financial benefits.

In addition to the multi-line discount, Amica also offers claim-free discounts for homeowners who have not made any recent claims. This discount rewards responsible homeowners who have taken steps to maintain the safety and security of their properties. Amica recognizes and rewards responsible behavior, such as avoiding claims, as a sign of low risk.

Amica also offers discounts on automatic detection equipment since it is concerned about fire safety and home security. By installing security systems and fire alarms in your home, you can qualify for additional savings on your insurance premiums. These devices offer peace of mind and lower the risk of theft and fire, keeping your home safer.

As you can see, both Erie and Amica offer a range of discounts and savings opportunities to help homeowners reduce their insurance costs. Take advantage of discounts to save big while protecting your home and family. Explore options with your insurance agent to find the best coverage at the best price.

Compare The Best Insurance Quotes In The Country

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Customer Service Review

Customer service is a crucial aspect of any insurance provider. In this section, we will assess the customer service offered by Erie and Amica to help you gauge the level of support you can expect.

Customer Service at Erie

Erie Insurance Group has a strong reputation for providing exceptional customer service. They offer 24/7 claims reporting, a user-friendly website, and a dedicated customer service team available to answer any questions or concerns you may have about your homeowners’ insurance policy.

Customer Service at Amica

Amica Mutual strongly emphasizes customer satisfaction. It provides 24/7 claims reporting, online account management tools, and a responsive customer service team. Amica homeowners insurance covers appliances, adding extra value to its policies. This dedication to customer service has earned it numerous awards and recognitions.

With both Erie and Amica, you can expect reliable customer service and comprehensive coverage options for your homeowners’ insurance needs. Your preferences and circumstances may shape your decision, but this review offers a clear overview of each provider’s benefits. Choose the homeowners insurance that suits your needs and budget.

Erie vs. Amica Homeowners Insurance: Ratings Breakdown

The main ratings and customer reviews for Amica and Erie homeowners insurance are displayed in this table. The information provides a clear side-by-side assessment of their financial health, business procedures, and consumer happiness.

Amica excels in customer satisfaction with a J.D. Power score of 903 out of 1,000, surpassing Erie’s score of 880. Similarly, Amica edges ahead in Consumer Reports ratings, earning an 85/100 compared to Erie’s 82/100.

Insurance Business Ratings & Consumer Reviews: Erie vs. Amica Homeowners

Both companies, however, show good financial stability, earning an A+ rating from A.M. Best rating. Regarding complaints, Erie somewhat outshines Amica with a ratio of 0.60, whereas Amica’s is 0.73. In this comparison, Amica stands out as the market leader in consumer feedback, whereas Erie stays ahead of the competition when efficiently addressing concerns.

While their shares are smaller compared to bigger players, they still make an impact. The remainder of the market is divided among bigger rivals, with Erie controlling 4% and barely surpassing Amica at 3%.

Both companies are notable, even with lower shares: Amica for its high-end features and Erie for its affordable offerings. They have developed devoted clientele by concentrating on the things that are most important to their policyholders. This analysis emphasizes their distinct position in a cutthroat industry.

A user pointed out some great things about Erie homeowners insurance in a Reddit thread. They mentioned Erie’s guaranteed replacement cost, which covers rebuilding your home no matter how much costs increase. They also gave a shoutout to the Plus and Select bundles for adding some nice perks.

This review demonstrates why Erie is a solid option for homeowners looking for dependable, adaptable coverage. Erie offers policyholders good value and peace of mind with features like guaranteed replacement costs and numerous bundle options.

Pros and Cons of Erie Insurance

Pros

• Family-Friendly Pricing: Erie delivers economical premiums, such as $58/month for a 45-year-old man, making it an excellent choice for households aiming to save.
• Enhanced Sewer Backup Safeguard: Provides protection against overflow damages from sewers or drains, a feature missing in many standard policies.
• Local Support With Dedication: Erie gives customers tailored advice and trustworthy help through a broad network of agents. Unlock details in our Erie insurance review.

Cons

• Coverage Areas With Restrictions: The services are only available in a few states; this limits its reach to a broader audience.
• Simple Digital Tools: The platform is missing up-to-date features such as live claim tracking or adaptable policy changes on the internet

Compare The Best Insurance Quotes In The Country

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Pros and Cons of Amica

Pros

• Outstanding Support for Recovery From Fraud: This covers costs such as legal help and restoring credit, which is perfect for protecting oneself against identity theft.
• Customized Coverage for Home Office: Gives protection to work instruments, inventory, and responsibility. It is designed for small business owners who run their businesses from home.
• Highly Rated for Claims Service: Known for quick, efficient claims resolution and frequently praised in customer feedback.

Cons

• Expensive for Young Drivers: Monthly rates like $735 for a 16-year-old male are high. Learn more in our Amica insurance review.
• Limited In-Person Interaction: Heavily dependent on virtual communication, which may not appeal to clients who prefer face-to-face consultations.

Key Features of Erie and Amica Homeowners Insurance

Erie vs. Amica homeowners insurance revealed key strengths and drawbacks for each provider, helping highlight who might benefit most from their offerings. Erie stands out with affordable rates, such as $58/month for a 45-year-old male, and unique water backup coverage.

However, Amica has a J.D. Power and Associates insurance company ratings score of 903/1,000, great identity fraud protection, including reimbursement for legal fees, and a stellar customer satisfaction rating. Due to these unique qualities, both companies are positioned as competitive choices for homeowners looking for specific advantages and good value.

Spend time comparing several home insurance companies online to ensure you have the best coverage at the best cost. You can get a policy that precisely suits your needs for coverage and price by weighing your possibilities. Get started today by entering your ZIP code into our free quote tool.

Compare The Best Insurance Quotes In The Country

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption